
Raw Spread vs Standard Accounts: The Commission Maths for Automated Trading
A raw spread account and a standard account can cost very different amounts to run the same Expert Advisor, and the cheaper option is not the same for every strategy. The difference comes down to how each account charges: one builds the cost into a wider spread, the other adds a per-lot commission on top of a tight spread. This article walks through the maths, so you can work out which account type costs less for your own EA rather than guessing.
How the two account types charge for a trade
A standard account charges through the spread alone: the platform displays a spread that is already the broker’s income, and nothing else is added at execution. A raw spread account displays a narrower, market-derived spread, and the broker charges a separate commission per lot traded, applied to each order.
The numbers are visible in the platform. The MetaTrader 5 Market Watch help page explains where the spread and contract specification, including any commission, are shown in the terminal. The specification makes the terms visible, but the total cost only emerges when the commission is converted into the same units as the spread. The split matters beyond the arithmetic because it changes when the cost hits the account. Spread is embedded in the fill price, while a commission is deducted as a separate line after the trade opens, which alters the floating equity profile slightly and, with it, the margin arithmetic on very fast strategies. Both numbers should therefore appear in the comparison, not just the total.
Turning a per-lot commission into a spread equivalent
To compare the two account types you need both cost components in the same units. Take the commission per full lot in account currency and divide it by the pip value of one full lot on that instrument. The result is the commission expressed as a pips-equivalent spread width. Whether an account is raw or standard often follows the broker’s execution model, which our guide to ECN versus market maker brokers explains.
For example, if a commission is 6 units per full lot on an instrument where one pip on a full lot is worth 10 units, the commission equals 0.6 pips. Add that 0.6 to the raw spread to get the raw account’s true all-in cost per trade, and compare it directly with the standard account’s all-in spread. This example is illustrative — substitute your own broker’s figures before drawing conclusions.
Why trade frequency decides which account is cheaper
For a fixed lot size on a single pair, the per-trade comparison is what it is, and the cheaper per-lot option tends to stay cheaper as volume grows. What frequency changes is whether that difference matters to you, and whether the shape of the charges still holds at small sizes.
A scalping or high-frequency EA multiplies the per-trade difference across hundreds of trades a month, so a small advantage per trade becomes a large difference per month. It is also the case that commission accounts often carry a minimum charge per trade, which can make very small frequent orders disproportionately expensive, while the same strategy on larger lots spreads that minimum thin. Run the comparison at your actual average trade size, not at round illustrative numbers. The illustrative table below shows three scenarios and how the cheaper option can change as frequency and size move. Keep the figures you use in one place — the Broker & VPS Quick Reference in our free trader toolkit is one option.
Other costs that change the answer
Spread and commission are the headline, but they are not the whole bill. Swap on held positions, minimum lot constraints, margin requirements and account currency conversion all change the comparison if the EA holds trades or trades instruments priced in other currencies. A commission advantage on paper can be erased by a worse swap rate on the same pair.
Execution quality is a separate topic from account pricing: how fast orders fill, how often they slip, and whether requotes occur depend on the broker’s execution arrangements rather than on the account’s pricing model. Do not infer execution quality from the price of the account. Add to the list the practical barriers between the two account types: minimum deposits, minimum lot sizes and leverage settings can differ between them on the same platform, and a comparison that ignores these is incomplete before it starts. Keep the comparison to one instrument and one broker at a time, because cross-asset generalisations rarely hold. Swap, and where MT5 shows each cost, is covered in our guide to spread, commission and swaps.
Pull your EA’s recent trade history and count trades per month and average lot size. Look up the current spread and commission in the terminal, convert the commission to pips as described, and total both account types’ costs for a representative month. Include the swap line if the strategy holds overnight, and any other per-trade charges the account applies. Start the shortlist from our best brokers comparison, then pull the live figures from each broker’s own specification.
When the maths points one way, confirm the mechanics on a demo or small live account of the target type before migrating the full balance. Pricing is one decision; the account’s terms, execution and reliability are the rest.
FAQs
Is a raw spread account always cheaper for a scalping EA?
No. Which account is cheaper depends on the actual spread, commission and trade size. A scalping EA makes the difference large, but it does not make the raw account the winner in every case — compute it with your own figures.
How do I convert a per-lot commission into pips?
Divide the commission per full lot, in account currency, by the pip value of one full lot on that instrument. The result is the commission as a pip-equivalent, which can be added to the spread for a like-for-like comparison.
Do commissions count towards a stop-out?
A commission is deducted from the account when the order fills, so it reduces the balance and therefore the equity that margin level is calculated from. It is part of the account’s working capital, not separate from it.
Does the account type change execution quality?
The account type describes the pricing model, not the execution arrangements. Execution quality — fills, slippage and requotes — depends on the broker’s execution setup and can differ for reasons unrelated to how the account is priced.
Trading foreign exchange and CFDs on margin carries a high level of risk and may not be suitable for all investors. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

